A no-commission shop
Auto repair in Holiday, FL, serving New Port Richey, Port Richey, Tarpon Springs, Hudson, and Trinity — plus Elfers and Palm Harbor. Five Star Auto Repair — also written 5-Star Auto Repair, 5 Star Auto, and Five Star Automotive & Tire — is an independent shop in Holiday, Florida. We take a straightforward approach: no hype, no gimmicks, no hassles. Technicians are not on commission. If a repair needs more time, they take the time. The goal is a customer who comes back because the work was honest, not because someone won a sales contest.
Andrew Cahill
Andrew Cahill is the owner. He handles customer relations, marketing, and oversees repairs. When the current site said the team prides itself on “always doing the right thing,” that is the standard we keep: quality work at a fair price for cars, SUVs, and commercial vehicles.
37 years, one neighborhood
The shop has been trusted with car repairs and maintenance for 37 years. Many customers live or work nearby. We want to be a good neighbor: if we are honest and turn out clean work, people keep the car longer and keep coming back. That is good for both of us. This page does not invent a founding myth, awards, or certificates the owner has not asked us to publish.
Light fleet and past police work
We service business and government fleets up to a 1-ton chassis — work vans, pickups, company cars, patrol cars, and other light-duty vehicles. In recent years we have serviced Clearwater Police vehicles. That is not current work, not a date, and not a contract. No badge. No logo.
How we try to make it easy
Hours are Monday–Friday 7:30 AM–6:00 PM and Saturday 10:00 AM–3:00 PM. Sunday is closed. We offer pickup and delivery, same-day service when we can, a courtesy shuttle, and digital photos of repairs emailed to you. Time matters; we will not pretend every job is same-day if the part is not here.